Finding the most cost-effective solution can feel overwhelming when it comes to heating your home. You’ve probably heard of heat pumps as well as electric furnaces and space heaters as viable options, but how do they compare in terms of cost? While both provide warmth during colder months, their operating costs, efficiency, and initial investments can vary significantly. Heat pumps are often praised for their energy efficiency and ability to heat and cool your home, while electric heat offers simplicity and affordability upfront.

What Is a Heat Pump?

A heat pump is capable of both heating and cooling your house. A heat pump transmits heat from one location to another rather than creating it, like a furnace or electric heater does. In the winter, it pulls heat from the outside air and moves it inside. In the summer, it functions like an air conditioner, extracting heat from your house and expelling it outdoors.

Heat pumps are efficient because they can transfer heat rather than produce it. This makes heat pumps significantly more energy-efficient compared to electric heaters, which generate heat by converting electricity directly into heat energy. Heat pumps typically use a small amount of electricity to operate the compressor, but most of the heat they generate comes from the environment. This makes them a much more efficient choice for homeowners who want to save money on their heating bills.

Start-up Costs: Heat Pumps vs Electric Heat

When comparing heat pumps to electric heat, one of the most crucial considerations is the initial cost. Whole-home electric heating systems like furnaces are often less costly to install, especially if you have existing ductwork you can connect them to. Space heaters are affordable and do not need intricate ductwork at all, so installation cost is just a matter of plugging it in. If you’re simply looking to add heat to a single room or area, electric space heaters are often an affordable solution with minimal investment. Electric furnaces are relatively inexpensive as well, when compared to other furnace types.

Heat pumps, on the other hand, usually demand a larger initial expenditure. The cost of installing a heat pump system includes the unit itself as well as installation of air handlers, which can be more complex. Professionals must install both the interior and exterior components of a heat pump, and ducts may need to be installed if your property does not already have them. This means the installation process can be more expensive and time-consuming. However, there are ductless systems that don’t need ductwork installed and vastly reduce the complexity and cost of heat pump installation.

Still, while the initial cost of a heat pump may be higher, it’s essential to consider the long-term savings. A heat pump can save you money in the long run due to its superior energy efficiency. Over time, the difference in upfront costs could be offset by reduced energy bills. This makes heat pumps a more economical option in the long term even if the initial investment is higher. Space heaters and even modern electric furnaces uses much more electricity, and space heaters can also pose a fire risk. Worse yet, they only heat one room at a time and have to be turned off when you leave the room, causing it to become cold again so you have to start over when you return.

Energy Efficiency: Heart of the Cost Savings

The efficiency of a heating system is often measured by its Coefficient of Performance (COP). The COP tells you how much heat you get out of every unit of electricity you put in. Electric heat typically has a COP of 1, meaning that for every unit of energy used, only that same amount of heat is produced. Heat pumps, however, can have a COP of 3 to 5, depending on the model and environmental conditions. This means that for every unit of electricity the system uses, it produces three to five units of heat, making it far more efficient.

The result? Lower energy bills. During the winter season, a heat pump can use significantly less energy to heat your home compared to electric heat. While you’ll pay more for the unit and installation initially, the long-term savings on your energy bills can add up quickly, often making the heat pump the more affordable option over time.

Long-Term Operating Cost Comparison

Electric heaters tend to be expensive to run, especially in colder climates. Since they generate heat directly from electricity, they tend to use a lot of energy whether you use a space heater or electric furnace. While this might be fine for short-term heating needs, the costs quickly add up if you’re using electric heat as your primary source of warmth over a long period. For larger homes or homes in frigid climates, electric heat can lead to some hefty energy bills.

Heat pumps, on the other hand, provide much better operational efficiency. They are particularly efficient in moderate climates, where the temperature doesn’t often dip below freezing. In these regions, a heat pump can provide both heating and cooling with minimal energy use, making it an excellent option for year-round comfort. In colder climates like here in Oklahoma, you can get a cold-weather specialty heat pump and can even add additional heating sources to supplement the system. Even areas like this heat pumps are still more efficient than electric heat in most cases.

Weather Considerations

Electric heat, though not the most energy-efficient option and expensive to run for long stretches, does have an advantage when it comes to cold weather. It can provide steady, reliable heat even when temperatures drop well below freezing, making it a solid choice for homes in areas with harsh winters. While it may cost more to operate over time, it ensures your home stays warm when the coldest weather hits. But for climates like ours here in the greater Oklahoma City area, we often recommend using a hybrid system where a heat pump is paired with a furnace for backup. That gives you the efficiency of a heat pump and your furnace only turns on when needed for the coldest days.

If you can get a gas furnace, even better, but if you don’t have fuel lines, an electric furnace is still suitable when it’s only a backup heat source for your heat pump. This combination ensures that your home stays warm and comfortable during the coldest months, without sacrificing efficiency.

Maintenance Considerations

Heat pumps require more maintenance than electric heat. The outdoor unit, which transfers air for heating and cooling, needs to be kept clear of debris like leaves or dirt to prevent it from getting blocked. Filters should be cleaned or replaced regularly to maintain airflow, and the refrigerant levels must be checked periodically to ensure efficiency. These steps help keep the system running smoothly and efficiently.

Electric heaters, on the other hand, are more straightforward and require less upkeep. The primary electric furnace maintenance task involves clearing dust, dirt, and other build-up to prevent debris that could hinder performance, and having a technician check the electronic components. Space heaters require little maintenance and baseboard heaters mainly just need to be kept debris-free as well. Since electric heat doesn’t have many moving parts, there’s less risk of mechanical issues. It’s still important to have both systems inspected by a professional once a year to make sure everything is working properly. While heat pumps require a bit more attention, their efficiency typically makes the extra maintenance worth it.

Here to Help You

If you’re ready to make the switch or want to explore your options, True Climate Heat + Air in Oklahoma City is here to help. We also offer air conditioning repair, air conditioning installation, air conditioning emergency services, air purifiers, indoor air quality, and plumbing services. Contact us today.

company icon